Instagram Kristine Killingsworth and Keith Dewar remember their wedding day like it was yesterday.
Sure, the ceremony was being filmed for Lifetime's hit reality show Married at First Sight. And yes, the nuptials were the first time both parties would meet their spouses for the very first time. But the celebration also served as a brand-new chapter for two complete strangers.
"I didn't think I was going to get picked to be honest. I didn't think I was a real candidate but I got picked," Keith shared with E! News exclusively. "It gives me goose bumps to think of the day before and the day of my wedding. I couldn't sleep the night before."
Kristine added, "I was so scared. I remember being scared. But I made the commitment and I didn't want to run. I still get butterflies thinking about it. It felt like everything was going wrong that day."
Between rainy skies, a wedding dress sized a bit too big and a garter out of place, there were plenty of signs that this couldn't be a happily ever after. But three seasons later and this couple is proof that Married at First Sight really works.
"You just have to work it. You can't be the same old you and try to have a new life with someone new," Keith explained to us ahead of tonight's season premiere on Lifetime. Kristine added, "Because the same old you was not working out for yourself."
During their season, the Philadelphia couple put their trust in Dr. Pepper Schwartz, Pastor Calvin Roberson and Dr. Jessica Griffin. And when cameras went away, the pair still followed their advice.
Kristine and Keith praise Pastor Cal for reminding the pair to "always attack the problem and not each other" when having issues.
"It's helped us cut through issues a lot better," Kristine shared. Keith continued, "We're definitely two opposite people. We both have an understanding to try to understand the other person as best as we can. That's how our marriage works."
And while no relationship is perfect, both parties are grateful to have signed up for a show that provided so much more than a husband or wife.
"I had confidence issues and of course Kristine is Kristine and that will draw stuff out of me that would have never come out of me if I didn't meet her or get married to her or have to live with her. It brings out something that you're meant to be for better or for worse. It definitely made me stronger," Keith shared. "I appreciate that because I was a good person. I was always a nice person but I got taken advantage of so with more confidence, I appreciate Married at First Sight for that."
Kristine added, "I got a best friend and a partner out of this experience. I got to see issues of my own come to the forefront and be able to confront those and just push myself beyond what I felt like was my personal boundaries and limits."
Get excited for a brand new season featuring five new couples by checking in with more of your favorites below.
Jason Carrion & Cortney Hendrix
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced after five years
Doug Hehner & Jamie Otis
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Married and Proud Parents
Monet Bell & Vaughn Copland
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorced
Jaclyn Methuen & Ryan Ranellone
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced
Davina Kullar & Sean Varricchio
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorced
Ryan De Nino & Jessica Castro
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced
Ashley Doherty & David Norton
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorced
Samantha Role & Neil Bowlus
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorced
Vanessa Nelson & Tres Russell
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced
Lillian Vilchez & Tom Wilson
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced after 14 months of marriage
Heather Seidel & Derek Schwartz
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorced
Sonia Granados & Nick Pendergrast
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced; Nick now father of twins with girlfriend Heather Yerrid
Cody Knapek & Danielle DeGroot
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced
Sheila Downs & Nate Duhon
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced
Ashley Petta & Anthony D'Amico
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Together and Proud Parents
Molly Duff & Jonathan Francetic
Finale Status: Not Together
Current Status: Divorced. And in April 2019, he got engaged to the show's former marriage counselor, Dr. Jessica Griffin.
Jaclyn Schwartzberg & Ryan Buckley
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced after 10 months of marriage
Shawniece Jackson & Jephte Pierre
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Married and Proud Parents
Danielle Bergman & Bobby Dodd
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Married and Proud Parents
Mia Bally & Tristan Thompson
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced
Amber Martorana & Dave Flaherty
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Divorced
Gregory Okotie & Deonna McNeill
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Together and Parents to Baby Boy
Keith Dewar & Kristine Killingsworth
Finale Status: Married
Current Status: Married
Matthew Gwynne & Amber Bowles
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorcing
Elizabeth Bice & Jamie Thompson
Finale Status: Together
Current Status: Split. On June 30, 2023, Jamie announced on Instagram, "After months of deliberation with Beth, we were just unable to find common ground. I had really hoped to resolve this, but it feels like we have reached the point of no return. So, I made the decision to go ahead and file for divorce for the sake of my own mental health and wellbeing."
Jasmine McGriff & Will Guess
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorcing
AJ Vollmoeller & Stephanie Sersen
Finale Status: Married
Current Status: Married
Keith Manley & Iris Caldwell
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorcing
Taylor Dunklin & Brandon Reid
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorcing
Kate Sisk & Luke Cuccurullo
Finale Status: Separated
Current Status: Divorcing
Married at First Sight (produced by Kinetic Content) airs Wednesday nights at 8 p.m. on Lifetime. And follow Keith and Kristine's love story when Married at First Sight: Couples Cam returns July 23 at 8 p.m.