Turns out there are plenty of folks who do want this.
Netflix revealed Oct. 10 that they have renewed Nobody Wants This for a second season after the success of season one, which followed the story of an unlikely romance between an outspoken, agnostic podcast host (Kristen Bell) and an unconventional rabbi (Adam Brody).
"Nobody wants this to end," Netflix said in a video shared to X, formerly Twitter. "Let's make it official. Season 2 is on the way."
While there is currently no premiere date set for the Erin Foster-created show, the new season will be helmed by Girls alums Jenni Konner and Bruce Eric Kaplan, who will serve as executive producers and showrunners.
And for Foster—who is the daughter of music producer David Foster—getting to make a season two is something she is incredibly excited about.
"Creating Nobody Wants This will forever be a career highlight for me," she said in a statement. "The incredible cast, crew, producers and executives all made this into the show it is today, and to experience viewers' reactions to this series now that it's out in the world has been more than anything I could have dreamed. I'm so lucky to be able to continue this story, and to do it alongside Jenni Konner and Bruce Eric Kaplan, who I've been such a fan of since Girls… Justice for healthy relationships being the most romantic!"
Konner and Kaplan shared their own enthusiasm, with Konner saying, "It's a dream to be working on Nobody Wants This. Erin is the rare creator with a crystal clear voice and a genuinely collaborative spirit."
Kaplan added, "I am excited beyond belief to be a part of Season 2 of Nobody Wants This, created by the hilarious Erin Foster. It is such a unique and beautiful show and I am already having the best time working on it."
Even before season one of the show aired, Foster—who loosely based the show on her own romance with husband Simon Tikhman, for whom she converted to Judaism—was already thinking ahead to future seasons.
"We're getting a really positive response," she told IndieWire in September. "And so I think the conversations have definitely started to happen about a potential season two."
As the 42-year-old explained, "The story in season one unfolds really slowly. So I think if there is a season two I would want to just kind of pick up where we leave off and continue to take it slow, because I don't want us to get too far ahead of ourselves."
To see which other shows have been renewed or canceled so far this year, keep reading.
Renewed: Black Doves
The spy thriller was renewed for a second season, Netflix confirmed.
Renewed: Tell Me Lies
The Hulu drama will be back for season three.
Renewed: Mayor of Kingstown
The Paramount+ drama starring Jeremy Renner will return for its fourth season next year.
Renewed: Bad Monkey
Vince Vaughn returns for season two of the AppleTV+ comedy.
Renewed: A Man on the Inside
The Netflix comedy starring Ted Danson returns for season two in 2025.
Renewed: The Kelly Clarkson Show
Kelly Clarkson's daytime talk show will be back for season seven.
Renewed: Silo
Apple TV+'s world-building drama has been renewed for third and fourth seasons.
Renewed: Farmer Wants a Wife
Kimberly Williams-Paisley will join the Fox reality competition dating show as host for season three, guiding four young farmers and daters as they look for real connections and true love.
Renewed: Like Water for Chocolate
The MAX drama, produced by Salma Hayek, will be back for season two.
Renewed: Rivals
The Hulu drama about English socialites in the 1980s returns for season two next year.
Renewed & Ending: Bel-Air
Peacock's reimagining of The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air returns for its fourth and final season in 2025.
Renewed: The Day of the Jackal
Peacock's spy drama starring Eddie Redmayne and Lashana Lynch was renewed for a second season.
Renewed: America's Sweethearts: Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders
Season two will follow the 2024-25 Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders squad from start to finish—kicking off at auditions and training camp and continuing all the way through the NFL season.
Renewed & Ending: Outer Banks
Netflix revealed that the hit teen drama is renewed for a fifth and final season five.
Renewed: Days of Our Lives
Peacock has renewed the long running TV soap opera for a historic 61st season.
Renewed: Matlock
The reimagined TV reboot starring Kathy Bates scored an early season two renewal.
Renewed: The McBee Dynasty: Real American Cowboys
The reality series about the McBee ranching family will move from Peacock to Bravo for season two.
Canceled & Picked Up: Project Runway
After it's landmark 20th season, the Bravo fashion design competition will be moving to Freeform and Hulu in 2025.
Renewed: Shrinking
The AppleTV+ comedy starring Jason Segel and Harrison Ford will be back for season three.
Renewed: The Diplomat
Netflix has renewed the critically-acclaimed political drama for a third season, ahead of its season two premiere on Oct. 31.
Renewed: Nobody Wants This
The breakout Netflix comedy starring Kristen Bell and Adam Brody has been renewed for a second season, slated to premiere in 2025.
Renewed: Reacher
Prior to its season three premiere in 2025, Prime Video announced the drama has been renewed for a fourth season.
Renewed: The Night Agent
Based on the novel by Matthew Quirk, The Night Agent is a sophisticated, character-based, action-thriller centering on a low level FBI Agent, Peter Sutherland, whose efforts to save The President in season one earn him an opportunity to become a Night Agent in season two. But working in the secretive organization of Night Action will propel Peter into a world where danger is everywhere and trust is in short supply.
The Netflix series will be back for season three next year.
Renewed: The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives
The hit Hulu reality show is returning for season two.
“There was a philosophical question raised in season one which was ‘Can #MomTok survive this?’ The answer unequivocally is yes!" said Rob Mills, Executive Vice President, Unscripted and Alternative Entertainment, Walt Disney Television. "Spring 2025 get your dirty sodas ready!”
Renewed: Sugar
The AppleTV+ drama has been renewed for a second season with Academy Award-nominee Colin Farrell set to return and reprise his role as Detective John Sugar.
Canceled: UnPrisoned
The Hulu comedy has been canceled after two seasons.
“Ladies & Gents, that is a wrap on Unprisoned,” star Kerry Washington announce don social media in September. “This beautiful show that we poured so much of our hearts and souls into is unfortunately not coming back for a Season 3. But I wanted you to hear it from me because while we’re super duper disappointed, we’re also crazy deeply grateful.”
Canceled: Pretty Little Liars
The reboot—originally titled Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin—was canceled by Max after two seasons.
Renewed: Industry
The HBO drama will return for season four.
On Pause: Coupe to Throuple
The polyamorous dating show “has not been canceled officially,” a Peacock spokeperson told Deadline, but “there are no plans for future seasons at this time.”
Renewed: Emily in Paris
Lily Collins and co. will be back for season five, Netflix announced. Plus, expect more adventures in Rome.