Darren Criss, Campbell "Pookie" Puckett, Rei Ami & More Stars Who Attended Heidi Klum’s Halloween Party

Darren Criss, Jett and Campbell Puckett and KPop Demon Hunters' star Rei Ami were among the celebs who went all out for Heidi Klum's 24th Annual Halloween Party in New York City on Oct. 31.

By Sabba Rahbar Nov 01, 2025 2:23 AM
| Updated 10 days ago
Tags
Watch: KPop Demon Hunters' Rei Ami Addresses Possibility of a Sequel (Exclusive)

These spooky, scary skeletons are ready to send shivers down your spine.

But there was so much more than just spooks as stars like Darren Criss and Jett Puckett and Campbell Puckett—better known as Pookie—hit the red carpet for Heidi Klum’s 24th Annual Halloween Party Presented by Butterfinger at the Hard Rock Hotel New York on Oct. 31—each and every one donned their finest Halloween costume for the iconic bash.

The Glee alum and wife Mia Swier opted for cartoon-forward looks with Darren donning a Shrek costume, with Mia dressed up as Puss in Boots.

Meanwhile, "Pookie" threw it back, dressing up as Elvis Presley and Priscilla Presley, while KPop Demon Hunters' star Rei Ami kept it meta, dressing up as her own character from the Netflix hit Zoey. 

As Heidi teased before the big day, she was already “hard at work” on her Halloween costume back in August.

“Of course, I’m going to do my Halloween party,” she shared on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon. “I’m gonna be extra ugly and super scary. Let’s not ruin it. We have exactly 86 days, but who’s counting?”

read
Heidi Klum Reveals Look at Spooky “Beginning” of Epic Halloween Costume

And as she looked back at some of her early costumes, the Project Runway star lamented the lack of creativity in the looks.

“Well, this is boring,” she complained of her first costume. “I was like, ‘I’m Heidi. I’m going to do a Heidi-themed dirndl-type thing in patent leather.’ But I had to do my own hair and makeup. I didn’t know anyone at the time who does special effects makeup.”

Now Heidi teams up with prosthetics designer Mike Morano, who previously helped transform her into Jessica Rabbit from Who Framed Roger Rabbit?, a worm and her most recent look.

John Nacion/Variety via Getty Images

And over the years, Heidi had taken great pride in making her costumes as wild as possible in an effort to encourage her guests to have more fun, too.

“By me doing crazy, elaborate outfits as the host, my hope had always been that all my guests would follow,” she shared with The Hollywood Reporter in 2018. “And it’s worked because, over the years, people have become increasingly more outrageous with their costumes.”

Keep reading to see all the stars and their costumes at Heidi’s 2025 Halloween party.

Tom Kaulitz & Heidi Klum

Ariana Madix

Remi Bader

Ilona Maher

Alexis Ren

Coco Austin & Ice-T

Mia Swier & Darren Criss

Coco Jones

Gigi Gorgeous

Amaya "Papaya" Espinal

Mariah Strongin

Ari Chambers

Kelly Bensimon

Heidi Wong

Amir Arison

Famke Janssen

Kate Barton & Kelsey Anderson

Rei Ami

Vivien Blotzki

Sofie Dossi

Anna Ermakova

Oliver Tarquin Gruber

Tamron Hall

Mia Swier & Darren Criss 

Jett Puckett & Campbell Puckett

Valentina Sampaio

Rebecca Mir & Massimo Sinato

Jonathan Cheban

Damian Hurley 

photos
View More Photos From Heidi Klum’s 2025 Halloween Party: All the Celebrity Costumes
For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App

Latest News