Christmas at the Arconia: 23 Only Murders in the Building-Inspired Christmas Gift ideas

It's Christmas in New York! We've rounded up everything you need feel like you're a resident at the Arconia, including merch inspired by Selena Gomez's character.

By Marenah Dobin, Lily Rose Dec 16, 2025 9:30 PM
| Updated Dec 16, 2025 9:31 PM
Tags
SHOP Christmas at the ArconiaE! Illustration/Etsy

What could be cozier than Christmastime at the Arconia? Bring the magic of Hulu's Only Murders in the Building home this holiday season with gifts inspired by the hit series. 

From merch with the Arconia's name on it to Only Murders in the Building makeup pouches, plus stickers, beanies, books, and looks inspired by Mabel Mora, this gift guide has something for every OMITB fan.

There's so much to love about the Hulu crime comedy from Steve Martin, Martin Short and Selena Gomez. Not to mention all the awesome guest stars like Meryl Streep, Paul RuddTina Fey, Jane Lynch, Jesse Williams, Zach Galifianakis, Molly Shannon, Eva Longoria, Eugene Levy, Melissa McCarthy, Cara Delevingne, Da'Vine Joy Randolph, and Sting.

We can't help but want more Mabel Mora, Oliver Putnam, and Charles-Haden Savage. Because of that, we've rounded up items every Arconiac has at the top of their Christmas 2025 wishlist.

Christmas Gifts Inspired By Only Murders in the Building 

Limited Charles Haden Savage Only Murders In The Building Vintage T-Shirt

Pay tribute to Charles-Haden Savage with a vintage-inspired tee that channels the iconic style and wit of Steve Martin's beloved character.

BLUPARK TV Show Inspired Makeup Bag- Only Murders in the Building

Use this pouch for your makeup, pencils or other small essentials.

Only Murders in the Building The Arconia Gold Logo Raglan Baseball Tee

Here's another shirt in homage to the iconic apartment building. It's available in many colors with sizes ranging from small to XXL.

Only Murders in the Building Officially Licensed Podcast Logo Tie Dye Hoodie

Get cozy in a stylish, conversation-starting sweatshirt that shows off your love for true crime and mystery in one chic piece.

Only Murders in the Building Stairs Logo T-Shirt

Celebrate your favorite whodunit series with a tee that perfectly blends comfort and intrigue, showcasing your fan status with a clever design.

Hulu Only Murders in The Building The Arconia Embroidered Hat

Show off your fandom in style with a sleek, embroidered cap that nods to your favorite mystery series with understated elegance.

Hulu Only Murders in the Building The Arconia 13 oz Engraved Cocktail Glass

Elevate your next mystery night with a cocktail glass that adds a touch of sophistication to your true crime viewing.

Only Murders In The Building Crew Neck Long Sleeve Black Adult Sweatshirt

Embrace the mystery in comfort with a classic long-sleeve sweatshirt that effortlessly blends your love for suspense with everyday style.

Only Murders in the Building Pyjama Set

Unwind in comfort with a playful pajama set that lets you indulge in your favorite mystery series even while you sleep.

The Arconia New York City Scented Soy Candle

Illuminate your space with a scented soy candle that evokes the charm and intrigue of your favorite show.

Only Murders Embroidered Sweatshirt

Add a touch of intrigue to your wardrobe with an embroidered piece that subtly celebrates your favorite mystery series.

Retro Oliver Putnam TShirt

Show your appreciation for Martin Short's memorable character Oliver Putnam with a retro-inspired tee that brings a touch of quirky charm to your wardrobe.

The Arconia Only Murders in the Building Shirt

This one's no mystery. This shirt from Etsy featuring "The Arconia" is a must-have for any fan.

Only Murders in The Building Mug

Same here, Mabel. 

Bloody Mabel - Kiss-Cut Stickers

Show your love for Mabel with this sticker. You can choose between three sizes, and you can put it on anything from notebooks to your laptop. 

Connectyle Classic Beanie

Speaking of Mabel, she really had the best outfits. All you need is this beanie, some red headphones, a yellow faux fur jacket and you can nail her look. 

Quartet Cork Board Bulletin Board

Want to solve more mysteries? This cork board is a must-have for laying out evidence and putting all the clues together. 

Scrabble

Who knew Scrabble could be so sexy? As the show taught us, this classic board game can make for a great date night in. 

read
What We Do in the Shadows Gifts for All…but Not You, Guillermo

Eioumax Real Paper Diversion Book Safe 

Keep your your treasures hidden in this neat book safe. It features a real paper cover and pages to make it look like an actual book. It also comes with two keys, an anti-lost rope and can blend in with other books easily. 

Limited Mabel Mora Only Murders In The Building Vintage T-Shirt

Fan out over Mabel Mora with this collage-adorned shirt.

Only Murders in the Building Arconia Windows Inspired Canvas Tote Bag

Carry your daily essentials in this Arconia-inspired tote bag.

Only Murders in the Building Birthday Card

This is the perfect card for your fellow fans.

OMITB Brazzos Mug

Just because Brazzos is a fictional series that doesn't mean you cannot fan out with this mug.

The Under-$40 Body Oil Alix Earle Is 'Obsessed With' + Her Favorite Makeup Duo & Holiday Picks

Latest News