Jessica Simpson as Lady
Those big brown eyes! Those beautiful fluffy ears curls! How could anyone else portray Lady and the Tramp's sweet pet?
Andrew Garfield as Tramp
Yeah, he's the amazing Spider-Man, but we also see the dreamy dude as Lady and the Tramp's lovable street-smart scamp.
Dev Patel as Aladdin
The British Slumdog Millionaire cutie is just the guy to play the adorable "diamond in the rough."
Emmanuelle Chriqui as Princess Jasmine
The Entourage babe looks ready for the royal role, no?
Tom Welling as Prince Eric
We're pretty sure the Gods cloned The Little Mermaid's Prince Eric when they created the Smallville star. Seriously, just look at that picture!
JoAnna Garcia as Princess Ariel
One of our favorite redheads in the business, we're dying to have Garcia back on our TV screens! And what better way to return than as the beautiful and rebellious Ariel from The Little Mermaid?!
Josh Holloway as Robin Hood
Roguishly handsome, this Lost alum is no stranger to playing heroic outlaws. Holloway totally fits the part of the skilled archer and swordsman known for "stealing from the rich and giving to the poor."
Evangeline Lilly as Maid Marian
With Holloway as Robin Hood and Lilly as Marian, OUaT would be staging an epic reunion Lost fans are dying to see: Sawyer and Kate together again on the small screen. (Just don't tell Jack or Juliet!)
Colin Ford as Peter Pan
Best known for playing young Sam Winchester on Supernatural, Ford, with his boyish charm and heartbreaking smile, is perfect for the boy who wouldn't grow up.
Dustin Hoffman as Captain Hook
See: Hook. Need we say more?
Chloe Moretz as Wendy
The Kick-Ass and Let Me In star is so insanely talented, we'd cast her on all of our favorite shows if we could. But we think she'd bring a lot of depth (and spunk) to the role of Wendy, "mother" of the Lost Boys and the only girl that could get Peter to at least consider growing up.
Bette Midler as the Queen of Hearts
If you've seen the Halloween classic Hocus Pocus, you know Midler would own this positively wicked role and have a blast doing so.
Elle Fanning as Alice
Cute as a button and bursting with talent, the Super 8 star is no stranger to Alice in Wonderland: she played a troubled young girl devoted to the story in 2009's Phoebe in Wonderland.
Matt Bomer as Prince Philip
The White Collar star is basically the closest thing to a real-life Disney prince ever. Why settle for mediocre when Bomer's basically the real thing? (Seriously, those eyes. And face. And hair. And smile. And abs...)
Dianna Agron as Aurora
The Glee star is just so preeeeetty. Who wouldn't want to wake this Sleeping Beauty up with a kiss?
Zach Levi as Flynn Rider
Levi is Rider. Rider is Levi. There is no other option. And with Chuck coming to an end soon (all the tears!), we're going to need to get our Levi fix from somewhere so why not Once?
Amber Heard as Rapunzel
Rapunzel, Rapunzel, let down your hair...so Heard, from NBC's canceled Playboy Club, can climb her way back onto our TV's!