Annaliese Puccini & Kamil Nicalek
Status: Split
A couple throughout Bachelor in Paradise season five, Annaliese Puccini (she competed for Arie's heart) and Kamil Nicalek (from Becca's season) called it quits during the reality show's reunion episode in 2018.
Jordan Kimball & Jenna Cooper
Status: Split
Just one day after Jordan Kimball's proposal was aired in the Bachelor in Paradise season five finale in 2018, the model (who was on Becca's season) took to Instagram to reveal he and Jenna Cooper (she dated Arie) had ended their engagement after allegations surfaced that the social media manager was cheating on him.
In January 2022, Jordan married Christina Creedon.
Becca Kufrin & Garrett Yrigoyen
Status: Split
Arriving in a mini van and declaring his hope "to be a great dad," medical sales rep Garrett Yrigoyen rode away with the publicist's first impression rose and her heart, proposing on the 2018 finale.
Kufrin stood by her fiancé as he apologized for double-tapping transphobic and homophobic Instagram posts. But the murder of George Floyd ignited new hard talks. "I was like...what's important to me?" she explained to Insider. "Are we going to be able to make a lasting relationship for a lifetime off of our differences?" Months later, the pair announced their split.
Ashley Iaconetti & Jared Haibon
Status: Married
It's Bachelor Nation's IRL rom-com, as the BFFs fell in love three years after Ashley I. first cried over Jared Haibon on Bachelor in Paradise. After revealing they were together in a 45-minute episode of her web series The Story of Us, much to the delight of fans, Jared got down on one knee in 2018 during production on season five of the spin-off. The two wed in August 2019.
In January 2022, Ashley and Jared welcomed their first child, son Dawson. Their second baby—a son named Hayden—was born in July 2024.
Clare Crawley & Benoit Beausejour-Savard
Status: Split
While Clare sent Benoit Beausejour-Savard packing during The Bachelor Winter Games, they shocked everyone by getting together after the show. The Canadian sweetheart popped the question during the 2018 reunion taping, and Clare's brief jacuzzi argument with German Christian was all but forgotten.
Less than two months later, the couple announced their break up in a joint Instagram post. "We do understand however, having a public engagement on TV kind of changes that. It's with a heavy heart that we have mutually decided to end our relationship," the former couple wrote.
Courtney Dober & Lily McManus
Status: Split
While they didn't get a ton of screentime during Winter Games, the finale revealed Australian Courtney Dober and New Zealander Lily McManus to be one heck of a couple. After touring the U.S. in an RV and documenting the entire thing on Instagram and Youtube, Lily and Courtney both posted lengthy and beautiful statements on their Instagrams explaining that they have decided to split, but remain friends.
"Lily and I have chosen not to end our relationship but to continue it as mates," Courtney wrote. "We're best friends and it's become clear to both of us that the emotional side of our relationship just doesn't allow us to be the best versions of ourselves."
"It makes my eyes leak a little bit but myself and Court have decided to split on mutual terms," Lily echoed. "I love Court with every ounce of my being, that long limbed f**k will be a part of my life for a very long time."
Dean Unglert & Lesley Murphy
Status: Split
After four months of dating post-Winter Games in 2018, E! News exclusively learned that Dean and Lesley Murphy had called it quits, with a source explaining, "Distance and traveling were a factor. They are both going to continue to be friendly and are on good terms, but their romantic relationship has ended."
Stassi Yaramchuk & Luke Pell
Status: Split
While they left Winter Games together, it was revealed during the reunion show that Luke Pell (one of JoJo Fletcher's finalists) didn't even get Swedish star Stassi Yaramchuk's phone number, and she never heard from him again.
Ashley Iaconetti & Kevin Wendt
Status: Split
Ashley I. finally got to leave a Bachelor show in a relationship, but her whirlwind romance with Canadian Kevin on 2018's The Bachelor Winter Games only lasted a few months before they parted ways.
Lacey Mark & Daniel Maguire
Status: Split
Digital marketing manager Lacey Mark (who competed for Nick's heart) seemed like a good fit for quirky Canadian model Daniel Maguire (one of JoJo's suitors). But shortly after leaving the fourth season of Bachelor in Paradise together in 2017, they called it quits.
Rachel Lindsay & Bryan Abasolo
Status: Split
While Rachel revealed before her season of The Bachelorette even began airing that she ended her journey engaged, fans had to wait until the dramatic finale to find out if it was Miami chiropractor Bryan Abasolo or Peter Kraus who put a ring on it. Rachel and Bryan celebrated their engagement with parties in Dallas and Miami, their respective hometowns. The two wed in August 2019.
But days after telling ex Viall on his podcast that they're "just in two totally different places" due to their wildly divergent work schedules, he legally filed to end their four-year union.
Nick Viall & Vanessa Grimaldi
Status: Split
Just five months after their finale aired in 2017, E! News exclusively reported Nick and Vanessa Grimaldi ended their engagement.
They've each gone onto rosier relationships. The Canadian special education teacher wed Joshua Wolfe in 2021 and welcomed their son Winston on her birthday the following September. Nick, meanwhile, told E! News he's "definitely anxious" to marry surgical technologist Natalie Joy after proposing in January 2023.
On the guest list: Their first child. "We definitely tossed around a lot of ideas," Natalie shared shortly after revealing she was expecting. "But I didn't want to feel rushed and moving it up. And then I have some pretty sick family members. And I didn't want to risk pushing it back. So we kind of just kept that and we're like, we'll just have a baby at our wedding."
Becca Tilley & Robert Graham
Status: Split
After both Becca Tilley (who appeared on Chris Soules' and Ben Higgins' seasons of The Bachelor) and Robert Graham (who competed on Desiree Hartsock's season of The Bachelorette and season one of Bachelor in Paradise) failed to find love, the Bachelor Nation alums began dating in 2016. E! News confirmed in May 2017 they had called it quits.
In May 2022, Becca unveiled her relationship with musician Hayley Kiyoko. They announced their engagement in July 2025.
Josh Murray & Amanda Stanton
Status: Split
After ending Bachelor in Paradise's third season engaged in 2016, despite some controversy surrounding his previous relationship with Bachelorette Andi Dorfman, Josh Murray moved in with Amanda and her two young daughters. However, after a few months, a source told E! News the "volatile" couple split.
Evan Bass & Carly Waddell
Status: Split
Though she initially rejected his advances, Carly Waddell finally fell for future husband Evan Bass during Bachelor in Paradise's third season, and the couple quickly moved in together in Nashville. Carly and Evan said "I do" in Bachelor in Paradise's fourth season premiere event, going on to welcome daughter Isabella Evelyn Bass in February 2018 and son Charles "Charlie" Wolf in November 2019.
However, in December 2020, they announced their decision to split. "We will always cherish our time together and continue to have the utmost respect for one another as we focus on what's best for the future of our family," they said in a statement to E! News. "We greatly appreciate everyone's love and support and kindly ask that you please respect our family's privacy as we navigate through this."
Grant Kemp & Lace Morris
Status: Split
After a tumultuous romance on Bachelor in Paradise season three in 2016, Grant Kemp (from JoJo's season) and Lace Morris (she competed for Ben's heart) ended the season engaged and moved in together. But after three months, the duo called it quits. So...about those "Grace" tattoos?
JoJo Fletcher & Jordan Rodgers
Status: Married
With doubters assuming real estate developer JoJo and former pro football player fiancé Jordan Rodgers would never make it to the end zone following their 2016 engagement, the athlete vowed to E! News that he'd do 1,000 jumping jacks "in a man thong" if they split within a year.
Let's just say Rodgers never had to suit up. Though the pair admitted they came awfully close to sending back her Neil Lane diamond ("We went through a lot of different struggles," said Fletcher), they tied the knot in May 2022 after six years and several COVID-related delays. "Knowing that you're married, it feels a little bit different, she shared with E! News. "You have that partner for life that's always going to be there for you."
Now in the middle of remodeling their Texas home, the hosts of The Big D are contemplating some fairly sizable decisions. "It's in the near future," she told E! of plans to expand their family, "one to two years."
Ben Higgins & Lauren Bushnell
Status: Split
After documenting their engagement (and ultimately postponing the wedding) on Freeform's Ben & Lauren: Happily Ever After?, Ben and Lauren Bushnell announced in May 2017 that they'd called the whole thing off.
"It is with heavy hearts that we announce our decision to go our separate ways," they told People in a joint statement. "We feel fortunate for the time we had together, and will remain friends with much love and respect for one another. We wish nothing but the best for each other, and ask for your support and understanding at this time."
As for why, "They just wanted different things. They had been struggling for a while...It was a mutual break up for the most part," a source close to Lauren told E! News. "I think Ben would have kept wanting to make it work, though. It's really sad. They're both such great people, honestly."
Tanner Tolbert & Jade Roper
Status: Married
Less than four months after Tanner Tolbert (the finance manager from Kaitlyn Bristowe's season) proposed to Jade Roper (one of Ben's finalists) on the season two finale of Bachelor in Paradise, the super-cute duo said "I do" in front of family, friends, many franchise alums and ABC's cameras in a ceremony in January 2016.
In August 2017, Jade and Tanner welcomed their first child, a girl named Emerson Avery. Jade welcomed the couple's second child, son Brooks Easton, in July 2019 via accidental home birth. Youngest son Reed came along in November 2020. In August 2023, Jade said on Instagram that she had a miscarriage.
Kaitlyn Bristowe & Shawn Booth
Status: Split
For the former dancer—who briefly shared lead duties with Britt Nilsson—and personal trainer Shawn Booth, the 2015 finale wasn't all that dramatic. "I never, never really had a doubt, like, ever," the BC Gym founder admitted on podcast Austin AF. "I was always like, 'Yep, she's gonna pick me.'"
Though the Nashville-based duo's engagement lasted three years, the bloom began to come off the rose earlier. "I think I knew for a year that my relationship wouldn't work, and I think I knew that he just couldn't give me the kind of love that I needed in my life," Bristowe shared on The Ben and Ashley I Almost Famous Podcast in 2019. "And I think for a solid year, maybe half a year, I was already grieving the relationship."
Chris Soules & Whitney Bischoff
Status: Split
Chris Soules and his fiancée Whitney Bischoff split a mere two months after the season 19 Bachelor proposed during the 2014 finale.
"Whitney Bischoff and Chris Soules have mutually and amicably decided to end their engagement," the couple said in a statement. "They part with nothing but respect and admiration for one another and will continue to be supportive friends. They wish to thank everyone who has supported them through this journey."
Marcus Grodd & Lacy Faddoul
Status: Split
While the duo swapped vows in Bachelor in Paradise's season two premiere, after ending the first season of the spinoff engaged in 2014, a source confirmed to E! News that Marcus Grodd and Lacy Faddoul called it quits less than one year after their wedding.
Or whatever you want to call it, with Marcus later revealing their Mexico nuptials weren't legal.
Cody Sattler & Michelle Money
Status: Split
Bachelor and Bachelor Pad alum Michelle Money unexpectedly fell for Cody Sattler, one of Andi Dorfman's castoffs, when they met on Bachelor in Paradise in 2014. The duo announced their split in a joint statement six months after season one aired.
Andi Dorfman& Josh Murray
Status: Split
"I didn't think I found my soulmate," the assistant district attorney said of accepting former pro baseball player Josh Murray's proposal on her July 2014 finale. "I knew it. I was 100 percent sure." By January, though, they had split. Her verdict, she told then-host Chris Harrison in a Bachelor special, "We were both very aware of the fact that we just didn't better each other."
She later accused him of being emotionally and verbally abusive in her 2016 book, It's Not Okay: Turning Heartbreak Into Happily Never After, which he called "ludicrous".
On May 31, the author married commercial real estate agent Blaine Hart in Italy, where they reconnected in 2021 more than 15 years after they first met.