If we could turn back time, we'd find a way to watch Andy Cohen's new video with his son for the first time all over again.
The Watch What Happens Live host shared an Instagram video on Sept. 16 of him and 3-year-old Benjamin discussing Cher after the Bravo producer apparently introduced the toddler to her music. "What did you think?" Andy asked Benjamin, only for him to hilariously respond, "She was singing too loud for me."
"She was singing too loud for you?! You loved it!" Andy said, adding that Cher reminded Benjamin of Elsa from Frozen "because they're both good singers."
Benjamin, meanwhile, remained adamant that the "Believe" singer was simply too loud. The father and son adorably went back and forth a few times until Andy jokingly laid down the law. "Ben, it was Cher and there's gonna be a lot of Cher in your life, do you know that?" he said. "Lots of Cher to come!"
Speaking of Cher, Andy added, "And sharing is good too."
Watch the cute exchange in the above video, and keep reading to see a few of Benjamin's most adorable photos.
New York Institutions
A fireman, a ball player and a fairy princess cross the street on Halloween in 2024.
Age Is But a Number
"Lucy is Two! It is so exciting getting to know my daughter; she’s a smart, funny sweetheart who surprises me every day," Andy wrote in a sweet birthday tribute April 29, 2024. "And the female energy Lucy is shining all over this house is welcome and needed! It’s getting really fun over here!"
He continued, "Marking time through the filter of my children’s growth is blowing my mind at this later stage of my life. Everything feels on double-time but it’s also, as @hodakotb says, right on time."
Up on the Roof
Andy and Ben had a bird's-eye view of the April 8, 2024, solar eclipse.
Bring Your Daughter to BravoCon
"Bring your Daughter to #BravoCon Day!" Andy posted on Instagram in October 2022.
Sweet As Pie
"She is so bright-eyed & sweet as [pie emoji]," Andy wrote on Instagram in September 2022.
Summer Baby
Andy shared this photo of Lucy in August 2022.
A Family of Three
Andy shared this sweet snapshot of him and his two children in July.
Sibling Bonding
It didn't take long for Benjamin to embrace the role of big bro.
Big Brother Benjamin
Andy announced the birth of his second child, a daughter named Lucy Eve Cohen, born via surrogate in April.
Taking Over the Family Business
Ben and Anderson Cooper's son Wyatt are clearly destined to follow in their fathers' footsteps.
Benjamin Is 3!
Benjamin joins his dad for his star ceremony on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on Feb. 4, 2022, his third birthday.
Benjamin & John Mayer
The musician, who helped induct Andy to the Hollywood Walk of Fame, hangs out with the star's son at the ceremony.
Benjamin & Pee Paw
In September 2021, Andy shared on Instagram this photo of Mark Consuelos with his son, revealing that he calls him "Pee Paw."
Benjamin & Mee Maw
In September 2021, Andy shared this photo of Kelly Ripa with his son, revealing that he calls her "Mee Maw."
Happy Father's Day 2021
Andy and his son celebrate Father's Day.
Halloween 2020
Andy appears with his son outside a fire station for Halloween 2020.
Beach Baby
Andy and his son relax on a beach in September 2020.
Beach Time
Andy and his son visit a beach in August 2020.
May the Force Be With You
Andy and his son engage in an epic lightsaber battle in June 2020.
Twinning!
Andy and his son wear matching outfits in May 2020.
Super Selfie
Andy poses with his son in October 2019.
First Birthday as a Dad
Cohen poses for a cute selfie with his son on his 51st birthday.
Flying the Coop
It's Uncle Anderson Cooper again!
Easter Bunnies
Baby Benjamin celebrated his first Easter in cute pajamas snuggling up to his proud papa, Andy Cohen.
Spring Baby
As soon as spring hit in NYC, the Cohen men were out and ready to soak up the sun.
Play Ball!
Benjamin was excited about MLB Opening Day in St. Louis as he showcased his Cardinals pride, a gift from team pitcher Michael Wacha, who Cohen named his dog after.
Guess Who?
Benjamin met Mark Consuelos in early 2019 and we are forever jealous.
King Ben
"Ben is ready for the #RHOA finale in his King-wear, gift from @porsha4real! What a trip! #KingBen," Cohen wrote on Instagram.
Who's That?
"The 40-Day-Old Virgin," Cohen captioned this adorable snap on Instagram.
Future Tonight Show Guest
Benjamin has already met Jimmy Fallon so clearly he'll be appearing on The Tonight Show in no time.
Get more of Andy on Watch What Happens Live, airing Sunday through Thursday at 10 p.m. on Bravo.
(E! and Bravo are both part of the NBCUniversal family.)