Exclusive

How Mormon Wives' Mayci Neeley Navigated the Tragic Death of Her Son's Father

In Mayci Neeley’s book Told You So, the Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star detailed the 2015 car accident that killed her college boyfriend, who was texting her at the time of the crash.

By Jess Cohen Oct 07, 2025 10:00 AMTags
Watch: Taylor Frankie Paul & More #MomTok Stars: Meet 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' Cast!

By the time Mayci Neeley appeared on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, she’d already faced some of the most difficult chapters of her life, including the death of her boyfriend Arik Mack.

As the Hulu star shared in her memoir Told You So, released Oct. 7, Arik was killed in a car accident in March 2015 when they were both 19 years old. At the time of the crash, Arik was texting Mayci, who was 14 weeks pregnant with their son Hudson, apologizing for cheating on her.

"The day my boyfriend dies, he texts me to say he's sorry," Mayci recalled in Told You So. "He loves me. He'll never forgive himself for hurting me while I'm pregnant with his baby. Arik's text ends with a typo. A singular letter J."

It wasn't until a few hours later, while scrolling on Instagram, that she learned of Arik's death. According to a March 2015 article published by local Utah outlet KSL, citing highway patrol, a Honda Element “crossed the center divider," hitting a westbound semitruck head-on. Arik died at the scene.

The tragedy was one of the hardest topics for Mayci to write about in her memoir.

"I do still have that grief," she told E! News in an exclusive interview, "and it's a part of me, regardless of writing it or not."

read
Mormon Wives Season 3 Trailer: Jessi Ngatikaura Gets Emotional Amid Affair Rumors

"Every March, which is the month he passed away," Mayci noted, "there just feels like there's an extra bit of heaviness and gloom in my life."

Since Arik’s passing, Hudson has kept Mayci moving forward.

"I've always called him my saving grace, because I don't think I'd be here without him," Mayci shared. "I became a more motivated, driven person."

Simon & Schuster, Lindsey Stewart Photography

At the time of Hudson's birth, Mayci—who married Jacob Neeley in 2018 and has since welcomed daughters Harlow and Charli—was preparing to be a single mom.

"I wanted him to grow up and be proud of me," the BYU alum said, "that I accomplished all these things and he did it with me, by my side, graduating college and finishing my tennis career."

"When I graduated, I made sure that he was there in the audience, and that he was a witness to a lot of my tennis matches and all the things," she added. "Because I want him to see these things growing up and being like, nothing can stop me either. My mom can do it, I can do it."

Told You So is available now.

Keep reading to meet the entire cast of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives...

Mayci Neeley

TikTok: 2.5 Million Followers

Instagram: 1.1 Million Followers

Mayci Neeley is married to Jacob Neeley with a blended family of three kids.

Taylor Frankie Paul

TikTok: 5.7 Million Followers

Instagram: 1.6 Million Followers

Taylor Frakie Paul shares two kids with her ex-husband and welcomed her third child with ex-boyfriend Dakota Mortensen.

Whitney Leavitt

TikTok: 3 Million Followers

Instagram: 982K Followers

Whitney Leavitt has three kids with her husband Conner Leavitt.

Layla Taylor

TikTok: 714K Followers

Instagram: 614K Followers

Layla Taylor is mom to two kids, who she shares with her ex-husband.

Demi Engemann

TikTok: 1.2 Million Followers

Instagram: 691K Followers

Demi Engemann and husband Bret Engemann have a blended family with three kids.

Jessi Ngatikaura

TikTok: 1.3 Million Followers

Instagram: 1 Million Followers

Jessi Ngatikaura shares a daughter, son and stepdaughter with her husband Jordan Ngatikaura.

Jen Affleck

TikTok: 2.4 Million Followers

Instagram: 1.3 Million Followers

Jen Affleck and husband Zac Affleck have three kids together.

Mikayla Matthews

TikTok: 3.3 Million Followers

Instagram: 1.1 Million Followers

Mikayla Matthews and husband Jace Terry are parents to four kids.