1. The Flash—Drama, the CW
What It's About: Glee star Grant Gustin plays the iconic DC character in this Arrow spinoff from producer extraordinaire Greg Berlanti. The trailer looks like a movie, and we're pretty sure it broke the CW's bank. Love.
Who's In It: Grant Gustin, Tom Cavanagh, and Jesse L. Martin.
Trailer Rating: A+. The #1 trailer of the season. Congrats, guy we once hated for trying to steal Blaine away!
Watch the Trailer
2. How To Get Away With Murder—Drama, ABC
What It's About: This new drama series from Shonda Rhimes centers around a group of law school students who get sucked into the tangled web of a real-life murder.
Who's In It: Viola Davis
Trailer Rating: A. Hands down the surest bet of the season, what with Rhimes owning all of Thursday night and all.
Watch the Trailer
3. Gotham—Drama, Fox
What It's About: Batman origin series, following Det. Jim Gordon and the Gotham City Police Department. Catwoman and The Penguin are there, too, and look crazy-ass cool.
Who's In It: Ben McKenzie, Donal Logue and Jada Pinkett-Smith
Trailer Rating: A. So much yes.
Watch the Trailer
4. Marry Me—Comedy, NBC
What It's About: It's Happy Endings 2.0! (Basically.) Ken Marino and Casey Wilson play a long-time couple looking to get married.
Who's In It: Ken Marino, Casey Wilson
Trailer Rating: A. The casting is spot on, the writing comes from the guys who wrote Happy Endings, and the trailer looks amaahhhhzing. Win!
Watch the Trailer
5. Stalker—Drama, CBS
What's It About: Two super-hot detectives who investigate dangerous stalker incidents. (‘Cause when you look like Maggie Q, you want to surround yourself with stalkers. Duh.)
Who's In It: Maggie Q, Dylan McDermott
Trailer Rating: A. $%*&#! Scary. As. Hell.
Watch the Trailer
6. Gracepoint—Fall Event Series, Fox
What It's About: Based on the UK's flawless series Broadchurch, this Fox reboot centers on a murder in a small town.
Who's In It: David Tennant and Anna Gunn
Trailer Rating: A- We still don't get it. (Is it the same plot? Different? How?!) But we don't even care. The UK version, Broadchurch, was so insanely good, we are in.
Watch the Trailer
7. Fresh Off The Boat—Comedy, ABC
What It's About: Centers on a 12-year-old boy as he and his immigrant family adjust to life in suburban Florida.
Who's In It: Randall Park, Paul Sheer, Constance Wu, and Aubrey K. Miller
Trailer Rating: A-. Surprisingly...funny. We laughed a lot. The mom for all the awards.
Watch the Trailer
8. Galavant—Comedy, ABC
What It's About: A musical fairy tale that follows a prince's quest for revenge. You read that right.
Who's In It: Vinnie Jones, Joshua Sasse, Timothy Omundson, Mallory Jansen, Karen David and Luke Youngblood
Trailer Rating: A for the cajones alone, ABC. This will either be a huge breakout hit or the season's biggest flop.
Watch the Trailer
9. Scorpion—Drama, CBS
What's It About: Eccentric genius and his team of misfits battle against high tech threats to national security.
Who's In It: Elyes Gabel, Robert Patrick, Katharine McPhee
Trailer Rating: B. (Don't worry, Kat McPhee is not playing one of the geniuses.)
Watch the Trailer
10. Secrets And Lies—Drama, ABC
What It's About: A man who looks a lot like Ryan Phillipe (OK, it is) discovers the body of his neighbor's son and things don't go well from there.
Who's In It: Ryan Phillipe, KaDee Strickland and Juliette Lewis
Trailer Rating: B. We're pretty sure this is a complete rip-off of Broadchurch but we're still intrigued.
Watch the Trailer
11. Red Band Society—Dramedy, Fox
What It's About: Like the Breakfast Club, in a kids' hospital. Whee! The premise sounds terribly depressing, but trailer looks inspirational.
Who's In It: Octavia Spencer, Griffin Gluck, Charlie Rowe, Dave Annable, Brian Bradley, Ciara Bravo and Zoe Levin
Trailer Rating: B-. Promising. Also, Dave Annable. Also, Dave Annable's dimples.
Watch the Trailer
12. Mulaney—Comedy, Fox
What It's About: An aspiring comic gets a job writing jokes for a narcissistic comedian.
Who's In It: John Mulaney, Martin Short, Nasim Pedrad, Seaton Smith and Elliott Gould
Trailer Rating: B- . Cute. Maybe? The premise feels a whole lot like Seinfeld. Wacky neighbor and all.
Watch the Trailer
13. Madam Secretary—Drama, CBS
What's It About: Elizabeth McCord, the newly appointed Secretary of State, balances work and family life.
Who's In It: Téa Leoni, Bebe Neuwirth, Geoffrey Arend, Patina Miller
Trailer Rating: C. We want to love it. We aren't sold.
Watch the Trailer
14. State Of Affairs—Drama, NBC
What It's About: CIA analyst Charleston Tucker must decide which international crises need to be brought to the attention of the president.
Who's In It: Katherine Heigl, Alfre Woodard, Adam Kaufman
Trailer Rating: C. The premise seems Scandal-ous, except, you know, no Olivia Pope. Izzie Stevens is back on TV, though!
Watch the Trailer
15. A To Z—Comedy, NBC
What It's About: A romantic guy tries to win the girl of his dreams.
Who's in It: Ben Feldman, Cristin Milioti
Trailer Rating: C. Cute. But the Mother deserved better. (Have you heard that one before, HIMYM fans?)
Watch the Trailer
16. Constantine—Drama, NBC
What It's About: A drama about a demon hunter from the DC Comics' classic series Hellblazer.
Who's In It: Matt Ryan, Lucy Griffiths, Harrold Perrineau
Trailer Rating: C. We do love Harold, though.
Watch the Trailer
17. NCIS: New Orleans—Drama, CBS
What's It About: The local field office investigates criminal cases involving military personnel.
Who's In It: Scott Bakula, Lucas Black, Zoe McLellan
Trailer Rating: C. Did nothing for us.
Watch the Trailer
18. Forever—Drama, ABC
What It's About: A medical examiner who just happens to be immortal.
Who's In It: Ioan Gruffudd, Alana De La Garza and Judd Hirsch
Trailer Rating: C-. Instantly forgettable.
Watch the Trailer
19. Cristela—Comedy, ABC
What It's About: A law student is torn between her dream job and her traditional Mexican-American family.
Who's In It: Cristela Alonzo, Carlos Ponce, Terri Hoyos, Andrew Leeds and Sam McMurray
Trailer Rating: C-. Jokes are decent. (Some.) Format feels as stale as that bag o' chips under your couch from 1998.
Watch the Trailer
20. Bad Judge—Comedy, NBC
What It's About: Rebecca Wright (Kate Walsh) is a wild party girl who also happens to be L.A.'s toughest criminal judge.
Who's In It: Kate Walsh, John Ducey, Tone Bell, Theodore Barnes.
Trailer Rating: We love Kate Walsh and want to love this show. The project is undergoing some recasting, so...Not writing this one off just yet.
Watch the Trailer
21. Jane The Virgin—Comedy, CW
What It's About: A smart young woman is accidentally artificially inseminated, resulting in her getting pregnant even though she's a virgin.
Who's In It: Gina Rodriguez, Justin Baldoni, Brett Dier, Andrea Navedo, and Ivonne Coll
Trailer Rating: D. Words cannot describe how much we hate this premise.
Watch the Trailer
22. Utopia—Fox, Unscripted Series
What It's About: 15 people move to an isolated, undeveloped location for a year (or two weeks, if the show is canceled) and attempt to build their own society from scratch.
Who's In It: TBD
Trailer Rating: D. Isn't this Big Brother camping?
Watch the Trailer
23. Black-ish—Comedy, ABC
What It's About: An upper-middle class black man struggles to raise his kids with a sense of cultural identity.
Who's In It: Anthony Anderson, Tracee Ellis-Ross and Laurence Fishburne
Trailer Rating: D. We are squirming so much it's hard to type.
Watch the Trailer
24. Selfie—Comedy, ABC
What It's About: After a 20-something woman finds herself the subject of an embarrassing viral video, she hires an image consultant to help her rescue her image.
Who's In It: Karen Gillan and John Cho
Trailer Rating: D-. The trailer is confusing and odd, and looks like a college project.
Watch the Trailer