2. The Affair
Sundays at 10 on Showtime
WHAT IT IS: Unlike anything on TV, the ambitious tells the tale of an affair between two married people, played by Dominic West and Ruth Wilson, from both of their point of views, as they are both questioned by police about a death. Also, Pacey Witter (aka Joshua Jackson) rides horses and wears cowboy hats and is brooding.
YOUR RANKING: #2 (95% loved it; 5% hated it)
CHANCES OF SURVIVAL: After some serious critical acclaim and online chatter, Showtime renewed The Affair for a second season. But who's point-of-view will the story be told from?!
MOST LOVED: 1. The Flash
Tuesdays at 8 p.m. on the CW
WHAT IT IS: The CW's latest DC Comics-based show (Thanks, Arrow!) stars former Glee baddie Grant Gustin as Barry Allen aka the Flash, the super hero-loving super hero.
YOUR RANKING: #1 (96% loved it; 4% hated it)
OUR RANKING: #4
CHANCES OF SURVIVAL: With DVR playback factored in, The Flash was the CW's highest-rated premiere ever, so basically, expect it to be renewed for 10 more seasons. (Just kidding...but not really.) And yes, it's already been picked up for a full season. (Insert some verion of a "That was quick!" pun here.]
NOW IT'S OUR TURN! SEE HOW WE RANKED ALL THE SHOWS FROM CRAZY GOOD TO CRAZY TERRIBLE!