NewsPhotosVideosShopKardashiansRoyalsTV Scoop
NewsPhotosVideosShopKardashiansRoyalsTV Scoop

We Ranked All of Live With Kelly's Co-Host Contenders

18 photos
Dec 27, 2016 5:56 PM
LINK COPIED!
Pin It
Live with Kelly
1/18
ABC

And Kelly Ripa's New Co-Host Should Be...

Live With Kelly and...TBD!

After seven months of a rotating roster of guest co-hosts, Live has yet to find a replacement for Michael Strahan...not that Kelly Ripa has minded the prolonged search, saying she's having "a great time."

But the show will eventually have to fill the seat full-time, so we decided to rank most of the contenders, including Jerry O'Connell, Jussie Smollett, Andy Cohen and more...


Pin It
2/18
Getty Images

Neil Patrick Harris

Another popular guest host, the How I Met Your Mother star recently said his busy schedule would keep him from adding permanent host to his resume. "I've got another good job," he told E! News. "I'm doing a series for Netflix that'll happen in January and that takes up well over half my year. So the rest of my time is spent with my family, chilling and relaxing."


Pin It
3/18
David M. Russell, Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Ryan Seacrest

Listen, the guy is always busy, so why not add a quick hour of fun banter with Kelly to his day? He's co-hosted six times and definitely has the effortless energy the show needs, but we don't see him deciding to join the show on daily basis.


Pin It
4/18
ABC

Morris Chestnut

Though he's currently starring on Fox's Rosewood, Chestnut has been able to co-host a few times and definitely has the charisma.


Pin It
5/18
David M. Russell, Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Jim Parsons

With The Big Bang Theory's end possibly in sight, the New York-based actor could easily transition to the Live desk after co-hosting three times. (But yeah, we don't see this as his next career move.)


Pin It
6/18
Bravo

Anderson Cooper

Kelly's BFF and top choice for the gig, but he chose to resign with CNN. "He's my life. He really is," Kelly told Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live. "He's the one that got away and keeps getting away and gets away all the time."

And that's why he didn't snag a higher spot on his list, as he's the one that got away for us, too.


Pin It
7/18
David M. Russell, Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Joel McHale

Though he currently has a new show on CBS, McHale definitely is funny enough for the job, has co-hosted six times and was in the mix for the gig back in 2011 after Regis Philbin departed the show.


Pin It
8/18
David M. Russell-Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Keegan-Michael Key

Funny? Check. Smart? Check. Handsome? Check. Chemistry with Kelly? Check. The Key & Peele creator and star impressed us the three times he hosted.


Pin It
9/18
David M. Russell, Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Jussie Smollett

The charming and charismatic Empire star has guest-hosted a lot in the past few months, but something tells us he may decide to focus on the hit Fox show and his music career before taking over in any permanent capacity.


Pin It
10/18
Live With Kelly and Michael

Mark Consuelos

While we think the husband-wife dynamic is fun for a morning talk show, and the couple has great banter, we're not sure it'll work on a permanent basis.


Pin It
11/18
Charles Sykes/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

Andy Cohen

One of Kelly's closest friends, the Watch What Happens Live host has said his deal with NBCUniversal couldn't make a permanent gig on Live! possible, though he did write in his book Superficial that he sometimes wishes he could do it.


Pin It
12/18
David M. Russell, Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Carrie Ann Inaba

The Dancing With the Stars judge has hosted alongside Kelly five times, and is the frontrunner among the female contenders, and she definitely has the energy for a daily morning talk show. But would she be able to make it work with Dancing With the Stars airing in the fall and spring?


Pin It
13/18
Jeffrey Neira/Disney-ABC via Getty Images

Josh Groban

The only thing people love more than Josh Groban's music? Josh Groban himself, as the fan-favorite sub has filled in four times and was even one of the network's top picks to be Regis Philbin's replacement before Michael Strahan landed the gig.


Pin It
14/18
David M. Russell, Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Busy Philipps

While we've loved her on Dawson's Creek and Cougar Town, we think Busy is best at just being Busy and would be a great permanent co-host.


Pin It
15/18
David M. Russell, Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Christian Slater

The Mr. Robot star is definitely interested in the gig, and has put in the time, co-hosting five times. "All I can say is I love doing it and who knows? We'll see what the future brings," the Golden Globe nominee recently told us, going on to gush that hosting Live! is the best way to start the day.


Pin It
16/18
ABC

Jerry O'Connell

It takes a lot of energy to be operating at the top your game each and every morning, and the Scream Queens star definitely has it. Plus, he wants the gig, and has guest-hosted the most amount of times (13) among all the contenders, including the epic annual Halloween episode.

"Jerry's staying super positive about it, but says he's totally in the dark on the selection process," a source shared with E! News. "If he's chosen, he says he'll probably be the last to know. He's adores Kelly though. If she asks, he'd love the job."


Pin It
17/18
WABC

Fred Savage

A fan-favorite guest host (he's appeared 11 times), the biggest con for the actor and director seems to be relocating his family from California to NYC.


Pin It
18/18
David M. Russell, Disney/ABC Home Entertainment and TV Distribution

Richard Curtis

The high school science teacher rocketed to the top of most people's Live co-host radars after he won a contest to be Kelly's partner-in-morning-chit-chat crime…and was quickly booked for multiple return visits. He's relatable and his easygoing personality and sense of humor could make him the perfect co-host.

CLICK: Relive Kelly and Michael's best moments


Next Gallery
2025 TV Premiere Dates
About UsSubscribeContact UsFAQCareersClosed CaptioningWatch Full EpisodesSitemapE! International TV ChannelsCustomer Support

Your source for entertainment news, celebrities, celeb news, and ​celebrity gossip. Check out the hottest fashion, photos, movies and TV shows!

Ad ChoicesPrivacy PolicyCA NoticeTerms of Service

© 2025 E! Entertainment Television, LLC A Versant Media Company. All rights reserved.