Madeline Zima as Tracey Barberato
Shield your eyes, Mr. Sheffield! The Nanny's little Grace Sheffield is all grown up and delivering coffee to a boy, having sex with said boy, and then getting (spoiler alert) brutally murdered by a box with the boy.
Matthew Lillard as Principal Bill Hastings
Bill might have killed a librarian and left her head in her bed along with an unknown male body, but we really don't yet know if he actually did.
Ashley Judd as Beverly
Beverly is "the new girl" at the Great Northern, but Ben Horne isn't sleeping with her...yet. She's real confused about the skunks, though.
Patrick Fischler as Duncan Todd
Duncan Todd is a man being controlled by some unknown person or force to do things like hire people for jobs, and that's about all we know.
Jennifer Jason Leigh as Chantal
Evil Cooper had big plans for Chantal and her husband to meet him at a specified time and place, but now he's in prison, so it's unclear if we'll see her again. But we're gonna guess probably?
Jessica Szohr as Renee
Szohr appeared as Renee, Shelly's friend who James might have his eye on.
Nafessa Williams as Jade
The star of the CW's upcoming Black Lightning played a kind but impatient prostitute who really had no time for "Dougie's" complete lack of mental faculties.
Josh McDermitt as Wise Guy
The Walking Dead star showed up for about ten seconds to tell Cooper he broke the slot machine.
Ethan Suplee and Sara Paxton as Bill and Candy Shaker
Cooper, while on his journey through the casino to "call for help," ran into some old & very confused friends of his fake(?) doppelganger, Dougie.
Brett Gelman as the Casino Supervisor
Let's just say the casino supervisor was not a fan of Mr. Jackpots.
Naomi Watts as Janey-E Jones
Dougie's wife wasn't too thrilled about her husband's disappearance, until she opened up the bag he was carrying and discovered enough money to pay off their mysterious debts. And even then, she wasn't too thrilled about "Dougie's" struggles to do things like put on clothes.
Pierce Gagnon as Sonny Jim Jones
Dougie's son, played by the adorable star of Looper, Extant, and One Tree Hill, was highly entertained by the guy who looked like his dad but somehow couldn't figure out how to put on a tie or drink a cup of coffee.
Michael Cera as Wally "Brando" Brennan
We had to watch it a few times before we stopped giggling long enough to hear what he was saying, but it appears that Lucy and Andy's son grew up to be the coolest kid in town. He's come to pay his respects to the dying Sheriff Harry S. Truman (his godfather) and to tell his parents they can turn his room into the study they've been dreaming of.