Wendy Williams as the Lips
Everything about the Lips was so very Wendy Williams, from the voice to the crystal-covered costume to the fact that she was sitting down for the whole performance. It was hardly a shock to see her take off that mask after all her flirting with Nick Cannon, but it was a wild ride. Those poor native New Yorkers!
Tom Bergeron as the Taco
Once we thought of the Taco possibly being Tom Bergeron, we couldn't possibly hear anyone else. But it was fun to discover that this guy we've grown so used to seeing as a host also has a voice of his own.
Joey Fatone as the Rabbit
It's not that we didn't figure out that it was Joey Fatone before it was confirmed to be Joey Fatone, but Joey really, really committed to being that Rabbit, and for that we commend him.
Jesse McCartney as the Turtle
Jesse McCartney being revealed as the Turtle (along with Bow Wow as the Frog) in the season three finale was like a much-needed shot of millennial adrenaline.
Bella Thorne as the Swan
Why is it just so entertaining to watch Ken fail to guess his old coworkers? The former Disney star just thought this would be really dope to do, and to quote the podcast Who? Weekly, extremely good form, Bella Thorne.
LaToya Jackson as the Alien
Any Jackson family member on that stage is a pretty big deal, and this show taught us that LaToya is a reserve police officer!
Wayne Brady as the Fox
Wayne Brady has always been known as a performer who could take on pretty much any genre or style as he did on Whose Line Is It Anyway, so his talent wasn't a surprise, but it was nice to see him take home the win for singing as himself (in a Fox costume).
Margaret Cho as the Poodle
Margaret Cho was the first reveal that really blew the panel's minds, since she and Ken Jeong had worked so closely together for so long and he didn't guess her at all.
Mickey Rourke as the Gremlin
Mickey Rourke ain't got no time for this game. The Oscar nominee took off his mask before a vote could even take place, and we can't say there wasn't something exciting about watching him give zero f--ks.
Gladys Knight as the Bee
Since Gladys took off her Bee mask, there have been several other high profile divas who have been on that stage. But Gladys was the first and most shocking and almost most embarrassing, since she lost to Donny Osmond and T-Pain.
Lil Wayne as the Robot
Seemed a little suspicious that one of the biggest stars of the bunch was revealed during the Super Bowl episode, but still: Lil Wayne was dressed up as a robot singing Lenny Kravitz, and that cannot be denied.
Sarah Palin as the Bear
If we'd had more than an episode to think about it, it would have been so obvious that Sarah Palin was the Bear. Her clues were not subtle. But we didn't, and so the reveal that it was former Vice Presidential candidate Sarah Palin who had been singing "Baby Got Back" was truly shocking.
Kandi Burruss as the Night Angel
Kandi Burruss had a successful music career before Real Housewives even existed, but it's easy to forget sometimes. We still don't know what a Night Angel is but we do know that Kandi's season four win felt 100 percent deserved.
T-Pain as the Monster
While some guessed T-Pain throughout the season, his reveal and win were thrilling because if you've heard of T-Pain, you associate him with autotune and you probably don't know much else about him. Discovering that he's such an incredible singer and performer, even in a giant barrel, was delightful.