Steven Strait
After leading the Sons of Ipswich as Caleb, Strait went on to star in 10,000 BC and Stop-Loss before making the move to TV in 2012's Magic City.
The 35-year-old currently stars on the Amazon original series The Expanse.
Sebastian Stan
Clearly, Stan has a thing for playing tortured souls.
Following his villainous turn as Chase Collins, Stan went on to guest star on Gossip Girl as bad boy Carter Baizen and dated series star Leighton Meester for two years.
In 2011, Stan made his debut in the Marvel Cinematic Universe as Bucky Barnes/Winter Soldier in Captain America: The First Avenger, going on to appear in six additional films and starring in the Disney+ series The Falcon and the Winter Soldier. The 39-year-old's credits also include The Martian and I, Tonya and he'll next appear in the highly anticipated Hulu miniseries Pam & Tommy, portraying rocker Tommy Lee.
Chace Crawford
While he played Tyler Simms, the coven member with the smallest amount of screen time, Crawford would go on to become one of the biggest stars among the cast, thanks to his turn as Nate Archibald on The CW's Gossip Girl.
After his six-year stay on the Upper East Side ended in 2012, Crawford appeared on ABC's Blood & Oil, as well as in films like Eloise and All About Nina. Crawford, 36, now stars in the Amazon original series The Boys.
Taylor Kitsch
The same year he played motorcycle-riding Pogue Parry, Kitsch began his five-year run on the acclaimed series Friday Night Lights as beloved football star Riggins.
In addition to FNL, the 40-year-old actor went on to star in John Carter, X-Men: Origins: Wolverine, Lone Survivor and 21 Bridges, as well as lead TV series such as True Detective and Waco.
Toby Hemingway
Following his time as coven troublemaker Reid, the British actor went on to appear in Black Swan, In Time and Battle Creek and popped up in episodes of CSI: Miami, Lethal Weapon and The Crossing.
Hemingway, 38, also played the love interest in Taylor Swift's 2010 music video for "Mine."
Laura Ramsey
In addition to playing Caleb's love interest Sarah in The Covenant in 2006, Ramsey also co-starred opposite Amanda Bynes and Channing Tatum in She's the Man.
Ramsey, 38, went on to appear in The Ruins, Somewhere and Are You Here and starred in the shortlived VH1 series Hindsight.
Jessica Lucas
Lucas, like Ramsey, also appeared in She's the Man the same year she played Pogue's girlfriend Kate before going on to join the casts of CSI in 2007, 90210 in 2008 and Melrose Place in 2009.
She also co-starred in films such as Cloverfield, Evil Dead, That Awkward Moment and Pompeii and, most recently, starred on the Fox dramas Gotham and The Resident.
The 35-year-old married chef Alex Jermasek in 2018.